A few more effects would have made this perfectAugust 13, 2009 Patrick D. Lynch(Lexington, KY) 1 out of 1 found this review helpful
I got the CD as a replacement for my LP copy of the same. It's quite a delight to play the bridge sound effects while driving around in my car. It's a shame that the CD is only a different format recording of the original LP and not a bit more. Reviewers mention sound effects from The Cage, and there are some effects from the pilot I would have loved to have heard on this CD that are not present. The laser cannon used on Talos 4 would have been a nice addition along with the very different transporter room sound effects with the heavy buzzing generators and longer cycle time before the very different beaming sounds kick in. Another nice addition would be to include separate tracks for the bridge effects used in The Cage as well as Where No Man Has Gone Before which are also different from the rest of the series.
For the bridge sequences, the stereo separation is very good which is most noticeable while playing the disc in my car. While not perfect, overall, this CD is a must have for any original series Star Trek fan. Some sound effects are so specific that the individual episodes they were designed for instantly spring to mind.
History in SoundsNovember 3, 2008 Mr. Richard D. Coreno(Berea, Ohio USA) This is a wonderful, historical recording that not only is a must for fans of the original series, but an intriguing release for Sci-Fi aficionados, those interested in the art of generating sound effects or collectors of the vast pop culture aspects of the 1960s.
The sounds generate a vision on what is being done by the actors and demonstrates a powerful aspect of the series. And there is an ambient aspect in the arrangement, comparable with an auditory experience in the avant-garde.
This is a fantastic trek to the stars...and back.
Disappointing But...October 8, 2008 Johnny Apollo(USA) 1 out of 2 found this review helpful
Unfortunately for me, this CD is a disappointment overall. Having said that, because I am a fan of the original series(only), I still give it a 4. The reason I say disappointing, is because somehow... the overwhelming majority of the sound effects are from one episode only - 'The Pilot'(the very first episode) w/ Capt. Pike. Oddly... for some reason, they also decided to include some sound effects from the Star Trek cartoon(WTF?)...
While 'The Pilot' is actually one of favorite episodes and the sound effects are very familar, this CD spends way too much time on this episode IMO. I believe, at this early point in the show, the sound effects are kinda crude/"1950ish"... Thankfully, the sound effects were made better in subsequent episodes. Unfortunately, these improved sound effects don't seem to be on this CD, ehem...
Now, this CD DOES include a few sound effects(and only a few) that are from the original series w/ Kirk. For me, this is what I expected there to be alot more of...hence the word: "disappointment". I'm actually surprised that TPTB released this CD the way they did - with this particular "collection of selections"... BUT, thankfully, and as I expected, there are no effects from the other Star Trek shows. This CD contains only... 'The Pilot', the cartoon...(WTF!) and a lonely few from the original series.
So, for the Star Trek fan out there, I would still have to say...BUY IT(no exclamation point). This is a must for your collection, yada, yada, yada. Just don't expect too much.
Excellent, but mostly from one very old episode w/o Shatner.April 27, 2005 Dr. Charles Xavier(New Jersey USA) 4 out of 4 found this review helpful
I listened to tracks 4,5,7,8,13, and 14.
Tracks 4,5,7, and 8 are DEFINITELY from the pilot episode
"The Menagerie" with Jeffrey Hunter (Captain Pike).
The long, drawn out transporter sequences on tracks 4 and 5
are easily recognizable from "The Menagerie", as is track 7
the Alien Planet Surface, and track 8 the Communicator Beeps
(it's the uncharacteristic "long beep" from "The Menagerie").
Track 14 the Warp Drive is a longish sequence and again sounds
suspiciously like the one heard on "The Menagerie".
As such, these sound tracks are not very representative of the
series, as the device sounds changed subtly but definitely
when NBC picked up the show with Shatner, Nimoy, et al, in 1966.
On the other hand, it's very nice for an old fan like me to have
access to these old, familiar sounds of a great T.V. show.
Thanks.
Needed it, got it, used itDecember 24, 2004 Richard K. Carson(Vashon Island, WA USA) 1 out of 2 found this review helpful
I am not and never have been a fan of Star Trek, but these effects are nevertheless etched into my memory and are amusing to hear and to use as an in-joke for the many others who instantly recognize them.
I do remain a fan of electronic music of the '50s and '60s, which was so prominently featured in movies and TV shows of the same era. I refer in particular to track 37, "Alien Planet Atmosphere #2," which is quite obviously inspired by the 1962 Iannis Xenakis piece "Bohor."
It is funny to hear what sounds like a dot-matrix printer (track 52, "Library Computer on Bridge") in an age when printers already are practically silent.
